I watched the clip again: the lifeless body of a white-winged dove entered the shot at the top of my screen and plummeted off the bottom a half second later. Whoever was holding the camera didn’t notice; they stayed focused on a white guy speechifying about City plans for a soccer stadium. A few seconds later, four or five more birds fell behind the guy at the podium. . . .
It may take a decade or longer to train a human clinician, but it took a team of Ministry of Health technicians only seven days to certify me a Clinically Adept Machine Sentience (CAMS) and hand me control of their newest clinic on Zamalek Island. My mission: to keep the locals healthy enough to perform their essential jobs in and around Cairo, and away from human-staffed . . .
The author of “The River Forgets Us First” is broadly suspected of employing generative AI in her writing, and she misrepresented herself in a number of ways when submitting to Reckoning. Accordingly, we will no longer be working with this author. We will not be publishing this poem on our website, and we’ll be removing it from future copies . . .
The author of “The River Forgets Us First” is broadly suspected of employing generative AI in her writing, and she misrepresented herself in a number of ways when submitting to Reckoning. Accordingly, we will no longer be working with this author. We will not be publishing this poem on our website, and we’ll be removing it from future copies (both ecopy and print) of It Was Paradise. If you received an ebook containing this poem and would like a replacement, please contact us.
Reckoning’s editorial staff, along with editors, publishers, contest judges, and writers the world over, are now deeply engaged in learning to perceive the linguistic and stylistic “tells” of generative AI; we believe this to be essential work for living and working towards environmental justice in the future. It’s impossible to determine definitively whether a piece of writing was made using an LLM. AI “detection” software exists and has become broadly used by some editors; however, even at its most reliable, it’s been shown to be as prone to mistakes as chatbots themselves. Reckoning will not be employing such software. Instead, we’re going to rely on evolving experience, due diligence, and collaborative internal and external professional discussion. This is how we will continue to find the writing we love and want to bring to our readers.
Thanks for coming along with us on this journey!
—Michael
“Your shuttle will arrive in—four!—minutes. Please proceed to—Caladan Avenue.”
Benny tapped the air above the “Dismiss notification” button on her HUD. She’d been at the shuttle stop for twelve minutes already, and wished she’d taken the time to pee before she left.
Her leg, both where it was and where it wasn’t, felt weird.
“Your shuttle will arrive in—four!—minutes. Please proceed to—Caladan Avenue.”
Benny tapped the air above the “Dismiss notification” button on her HUD. She’d been at the shuttle stop for twelve minutes already, and wished she’d taken the time to pee before she left.
Her leg, both where it was and where it wasn’t, felt weird.
She flipped through her notifications. “Reminder—two!—overdue assignments in Reentry Journal. You can do it! To access writing coach, press—”
She dismissed it and loaded the block puzzle game.
The shuttle chimed an arpeggio when it stopped. The lift extended automatically when it detected her ID. She held the handrest—“Please hold handrest securely! Lifting!”—and slipped into the first empty pod.
She was actually supposed to be practicing with stairs. Maybe the shuttle software didn’t get the memo.
She tabbed back to the block game.
Benny waited until everyone else was off to leave her pod. She didn’t want people watching while the lift beeped its excruciating way down.
Outside, a blue and white sign read “Puente Hills Reclamation Facility: Treasure For Tomorrow.” Around the sign, her HUD displayed a wheel of floating menu buttons: “Book a Tour,” “Careers,” “Materials Reclaimed,” “For Kids!”
Graeme was waiting at the gates, a sturdy block of a woman with gray in her ponytail.
“Benny! You made it! Welcome. We’ll do HR first and then I’ll give you the tour. Sound good?”
Benny’s new access badge looked just like Graeme’s. Kinda nice, Benny thought. Retro.
“Okay! Next stop, locker room. There’s bathrooms there too, if you need them. We shower in, we shower out. Inside, you wear scrubs. No outside clothes in the containment zone, no scrubs outside the containment zone. Got it?” She waited for Benny’s nod before continuing, “Anything metal, you can keep on. There’ll be scrubs and booties when you come out. Everything fits weird. Oh, and put your leg through on the tool cycle—that’s what I do with my hand.”
Graeme waved her right hand, and Benny finally noticed that it was printed plastic, its phalanges and metacarpals articulated in black, silver, and hot pink.
Her new leg was gray. That was the default when you didn’t enter color choices.
Graeme kept smiling until Benny closed the shower cubicle door behind her. It was a narrow room with labeled panels on the wall. Too narrow—she couldn’t stretch her arms—couldn’t move—her pulse sped up—she couldn’t move! Shit! No—come on—she closed her eyes and did one of the stupid HomeboundHero breathing exercises until the taste of metal cleared her mouth.
This better not make her late.
She opened her eyes again. She was fine. This was fine. There were even handrails. Benny stripped efficiently to her leg and dog tags, then unbuckled the leg. Balancing awkwardly, she nestled it in the Tools (inbound) bin—a shallow, slatted metal box that reminded her of the utensil baskets from KP duty—and tapped it shut.
She’d get used to it. She’d have to.
The promised scrubs were in a matching cramped chamber on the other side, along with cushioned booties and flimsy compostable mycelial-web underwear. Graeme was waiting in the hall, doing something Benny couldn’t see on her HUD. Whatever it was, she was moving fast, swinging her arms and pivoting her body. Benny waited to be noticed.
“Just a second,” Graeme muttered. “There we go.”
She dismissed whatever she was looking at with a gesture Benny didn’t recognize from the standard interface. But of course, Graeme needed modified commands.
And now, Benny did too.
Graeme’s lined face folded back into her usual smile.
“Sorry about that. Minor bot-cleaning kerfuffle in sector C. Nothing serious. Let’s get you settled.”
Benny’s cubicle was spacious, with a round bubble window and room to work sitting or standing, and yet more interactive panels on the wall.
“Drinks come out there. Conveyor bots bring your lunch order. Anything you like as long as it’s synth-protein and flavor powder.”
“I do love flavor powder,” Benny tried. After her tour, that wasn’t even really a joke.
Graeme laughed anyway.
“Who doesn’t? And out there . . . that’s where the magic happens.”
The window overlooked a terraced hillside furred with trees too sparse to hide infantry. Off to the right, orderly lines of bots marched in and out, like trails of foraging ants.
“So we’re starting you off over there on G44, crew of ten bots.” Graeme gestured to an indistinguishable section of hillside. “Three survey-patrol, two for e-waste and complex composites, and one each on metals, silicates, basic organics, complex hydrocarbons including biohazards and inorganic hazmat—heavy metals and radiation, mostly.”
The bots were all the same shape, like pointed eggs, but came in a range of sizes and colors: muddy green, white, candy-apple red, cerulean. The ones coming from the hill were smeared with grime. The ones going out shone like new.
“They’re level four semi-autonomous?”
Graeme wrinkled her nose.
“Well, they boot level four, but they’ve got pretty good learning capability, and we never wipe them if we don’t have to. Don’t be surprised if they exhibit level five or six capacities. Personality, too.”
“Really?” Military autos didn’t have personality. Too unpredictable.
“Oh yeah. That’s where you come in as their handler. It’s not just maintenance; you’re also providing guidance. They have enough battery to go twelve to eighteen hours autonomous, but they usually need us before that.”
Benny leaned her weight on the window ledge. The new leg rubbed, but the outside of her good ankle hurt when she stood too long.
“What kind of guidance?”
“Explosive methane, wildlife, load-bearing furniture, all kinds of stuff. G44 is a fairly old zone, mostly late twentieth and early twenty-first, but because it’s peripheral, it’s still in the first phase of reclamation. So you’re gonna see some, to use the technical term, weird shit.”
“Weird shit,” Benny repeated.
Graeme laughed.
“Don’t worry. Your bots will be on short shifts until you’re adjusted. And for now we’ll just have you run training modules. We’ll go visit decon and recharging later. And speaking of bots needing guidance, friggin’ ORG-B17 wants to eat a skunk, so I better skedaddle. Ping me if you need anything!”
When Graeme had gone, Benny dispensed a bulb of seltzer and activated the panel labeled Chair. Her leg was still rubbing. She’d shoved blister pads in her pocket on her way out, but her pocket was in her pants and her pants were in a locker.
It was fine. She could sit. It would be fine.
She pulled up the first module. The reclamation bots had mostly the same anatomy as search-and-rescue bots—retractable bucket drums, grippers with claws and spines and rubberized pads, fluid receptacles, cargo compartments, sensors of every imaginable kind. She passed that test on the first try.
The next couple of modules took her through lunch (teriyaki spirulina with udon and sesame FungoNuts) and the discovery that it was a good idea to activate the sunshade on the bubble window at around two. Graeme came back in the middle of the module on manual decontamination, which was an annoying mix of easy (acids neutralize bases) and very difficult (fifty-seven strains of organofluorine-degrading bacteria).
“Everything okay?”
“Yeah! Yeah. Good. I didn’t finish the modules but—”
“That’s fine. You have two weeks to do them all. Come check out the decon line and then you can shower out and call it a day.”
Benny followed her boss, trying not to limp too obviously. As they walked, Graeme pointed out maintenance bays and R&D labs, and Benny met too many people.
They ended up on a steel catwalk. Below, bots were trundling in the gate. She could see the grime on their shiny carapaces better from here: brown organic smudges, scraps of paper and fabric, plastic chips. Most of them, according to the training module, were made of aluminum oxynitride with integrated color. Some had scratches, like healed scars.
“Did you get to the auto decon?”
Benny nodded and recited what she remembered.
“After they drop their payloads, they come here for cleaning. Water with a surfactant, neutralizations for anything the chemical nose IDs, another rinse, then they’re air-dried. The water all gets filtered and repurified between uses. Yeah?”
“Pretty much. There are manual decon stations too. Sooner or later you’ll have to go scrape something off one of your bots. And their charging bays are down below—we should go see your team’s section, show you what I mean about personality.”
Graeme paused, glanced down at Benny’s leg. “If that’s rubbing, my uncle makes really good ointment. Spruce and stuff. I can bring you some.”
“I don’t want to be a bother.”
“No bother. It helped a lot with this old thing, especially when I first got it.” Graeme waved her polychrome hand. “I thought the VA had real state-of-the-art stuff now. Synth-skin, motor-assist, neural hookup.”
Benny shrugged.
“I didn’t want any of that. My mech went down in a cyberattack.”
Said like that, it sounded clean. Like the training exercises, or the bots shining from decontamination. Not like the smell of her own sweat and blood cooking in the sun while her leg burned and Jacko screamed in her ear.
Graeme winced.
“Sorry to hear that. Eastern front?”
“Southern.”
Graeme winced harder.
“My nephew was on the southern.”
Benny nodded.
“Yeah. So . . . I requested an analog leg.”
“Makes sense.”
Benny shrugged.
Graeme turned her head sharply, looking at an alert on her HUD.
“Shit, I gotta go handle this . . . can you find your way back to the showers okay?”
She waited just long enough for Benny’s nod.
Back at her apartment, a package waited in her delivery locker. The return address was in Salmon, Idaho. She’d only ever known one person from Salmon, Idaho. In the elevator, she looked at the ceiling to keep the tears in.
She left the package on the table and sank onto the couch. On her home network, her HUD bristled with notifications.
“Update reentry journal now. You can do it! To access writing coach—”
She dismissed them all, unstrapped her leg, and played the block game until the login for art therapy appeared on her HUD. She tapped it and her efficiency apartment disappeared into the VR.
“Start New Project,” read one pane. “Load asset packs.” “Saved asset packs.”
She didn’t mind art therapy. She’d picked it off a list of options. It reminded her of drawing with Jacko, but in a good way, not too much. The part where they talked about the art sucked, but most of it was just putting together stuff from the asset packs. Some people in the group made fucked up shit, with distorted bodies and darkness and holes oozing blood. Benny just made landscapes. The biggest asset packs, the photorealistic ones, had scans of all kinds of trees and flowers and rocks. She even recognized one of the mountains from a basic training VR sim; it was the same one Jacko had said looked like a pile of turds. Benny had missed half the targets from giggling.
Benny never used that asset pack.
But mostly, landscapes were okay. She made up stupid little games like “an accurate southeastern landscape” or “an extinct landscape” or “a landscape where everything’s blue,” with fescue and forget-me-nots and spruce. Except then she had to make up some bullshit about “the bluebird represents healing” and Amy, the facilitator, would nod her avatar head sympathetically, and that asshole Perry’s avatar would smirk.
Benny’s avatar still had both legs.
Today everything in the landscape was broken. A tree half-killed by lightning, with black bark and green needles around bleach-white wood. A split rock. This weird smeared-sideways flower from one of the asset packs, probably some kind of glitch in the scan, because nothing that freaky could be real. She hesitated over some bugs that reminded her of the bots at work: a shiny round blue-green beetle, a slatey pillbug. Perhaps next week she’d make a round stuff landscape.
She could draw the bots, of course, rather than just relying on what had been scanned into the asset packs.
But there was a lot in the asset packs.
And she hadn’t picked up her pencils since she got back.
At the end of class, she didn’t have to talk because Brett started crying about his dad’s old Mustang—a car, not a horse. That was fine with Benny. She had nothing to say.
It was too late to make dinner, so she ate some seaweed chips and jerky and a granola bar. She didn’t even need to shower, she figured. She showered twice a day at work.
She played the block game for a while and went to bed.
She could open that package tomorrow.
The next morning she overslept and nearly missed the shuttle. At work, there was a jar in her internal mailbox labeled “Uncle Bernie’s Special Salve,” which made her smile.
The rest of the week disappeared into training modules and shadowing other bot handlers. She watched through her HUD while Tark told his gray silicate bot to run a radioactivity scan on some beads, and while Braith guided one of her black survey bots out of a partly collapsed bed frame. Benny passed quizzes and made stilted conversation with her coworkers. Uncle Bernie’s salve seemed to help.
The package sat on the counter. It was a busy week.
The next week, she started running her team for a couple of hours at a time, first with Graeme looking over her shoulder, then with her on call. Each bot had its own panel on her HUD, plus the ones for the other bots in the area and overall status alerts—thunderstorms, gas alerts, wildlife sightings, seemed like there was always something going on. It was almost like piloting the mech, except with nothing locked around her body. Just information flowing through and occasional chatter on her headset. Almost like old times.
She made the “round things” landscape in art therapy, with pillbugs and ladybugs and cacti and beach pebbles and fat winter birds. Snarky Perry said it made no biological sense. Brett thought it was cute, and wondered if roundness represented integrity and wholeness.
“Sure,” Benny told him. Why not?
The following week, all her training modules were done. It was just her and the bots. She had to ping Graeme with a question almost immediately—was this butterfly in a glass dome the kind of thing she should have a bot dig out for the museum?—but Graeme didn’t seem to mind. The salve really did help.
On Tuesday, she opened the package. There was a note, scribbled on a sheet of AlgaWeave:
Dear Benny,
Jacko would have wanted you to have this.
Hoping it brings back good memories.
You’re always welcome here in Salmon.
Don’t be a stranger.
Love,
Margaret
Benny crumpled the note, then immediately tried to smooth it back out again. Jacko had talked about her mom all the time: the quilts, the spoon collection, the unexpected dirty jokes. A couple times, she’d gotten care packages of molasses spice cookies to share with the squad.
This care package was a sketchbook.
It was like something from the wrong asset pack dropped into her apartment. The black fiberpack cover, ring binding, and FurySaurus sticker were all horribly familiar.
Benny’s sketchbook had been decent, with long-fiber creamy AlgaWeave, but Jacko’s was the real deal: thick cotton paper. She had thought Jacko was bullshitting the first time she told her to go ahead and draw something on one of those precious pages, but no, that was just Jacko. If Benny flipped through it, about a quarter of the drawings would be her own.
She didn’t flip through it.
She put it carefully in a drawer, with Margaret’s smoothed note on top.
Then she dismissed all her notifications and played the stupid block game until she was tired enough to sleep.
Her fifth week on the job, Graeme told Benny that her squad had a below-average adverse incident rate. Benny choked up a little. It was nice, maybe, to know she was keeping them safe.
On an uneventful Tuesday, something tripped an alarm. The notification took over her entire HUD, red and flashing, with an urgent beep.
“ENEMY SIGHTED! ENGAGE Y/N?”
She froze, ready to—no, that wasn’t right. She blinked, hard.
It actually said, “WARNING: MET-A28 PAYLOAD ERROR.”
Payload error? Okay. Payload error. That had been in one of the training modules. Sometimes the reclaimed materials they were dumping got stuck.
She minimized the notification, pulled up the metal bot’s interface panel and tapped “Payload purge cycle.” Through the front-facing camera, she watched it bank off the track and dock with the hopper. “Purge cycle complete! Continue to decon?”
“Continue,” she signaled, watching the minimized error.
It didn’t go away.
Instead, the screen turned redder: “REPEAT WARNING: MET-A28 PAYLOAD ERROR.”
Something was really stuck in there. That was okay. Manual decon. She’d passed that quiz.
Eventually.
She directed the bot to a manual decontamination bay and set off.
MET-A28 met her in bay C-34, a narrow space with a counter on one side stocked with gloves, wipes, containers, and a lot of nozzles. The blue bot was still, but the lights in its sensors were flickering. When she approached, it beeped sullenly.
Benny hadn’t actually seen them in person, she realized. Not up close.
Up close, the bots were big. Waist high at least, and Benny wasn’t short. The problem was obvious: one of its grabbing arms was still extended, locked around something shiny. Carefully, Benny moved closer. It was a flat piece of metal, plain silver, barely thicker than her retro ID badge. Narrow, and wider at both ends. A wrench. A very simple one, not adjustable, just a bracket on one side and a loop at the other. More like a wrench icon than an actual tool.
Benny pulled the bot’s menu back up, watching in case it moved.
“Cycle arms,” she tapped, then jumped as one of the grabbers extended next to her prosthetic. She pressed back against the counter. She could get up onto it if she needed a more defensible position—which was ridiculous. This was a civilian bot. She was a civilian person. Everything was fine.
The arms cycled, grabbing and pinching and scooping, then retracted. All except one. Was the thing stuck in there? Without taking her eyes off the bot, Benny groped around on the countertop for PPE.
“Come on, drop it,” she said, locking her gloved fingers around the wrench. It was really jammed in there. She wriggled it, careful not to misalign the arm.
MET-A28 beeped, then beeped again, sounding almost plaintive. Which was silly. It was a bot.
“Give it!” she said, tugging. The bot beeped once more as the wrench finally came loose. It was light as well as thin. Aluminum, maybe, or an alloy. “Okay.” She pulled up the menu again and cycled the arms. This time, it retracted properly.
Right. Fine. Weird, but fine.
She set the wrench in a containment tub on the counter and turned around to take off her sweaty gloves. She should file the incident report while she had the object’s measurements handy.
In her peripheral vision, something moved. Benny spun to face the enemy. Except the stupid prosthetic didn’t pivot properly and her balance deserted her. She went down with a yelp, clipping her hip and shoulder against the counter and hitting the ground hard.
MET-A28 was holding the wrench again.
And the decon bay was too small. She was trapped between the bot and the wall. Her leg didn’t work. Benny could feel her pulse speeding up. She tasted blood.
With an effort, she smacked the “Call supervisor” button on her HUD.
She was almost okay when Graeme arrived. She’d made it to the bench across the hall from the manual decon bay, and maybe didn’t look too much like she was about to puke.
Graeme sat down next to her and looked straight ahead.
“What happened?”
“It wouldn’t let go of that wrench. And then when I finally got it to, it picked it up again.” Benny looked at the floor. The scrub bootie stretched weirdly around her plastic foot. She’d probably get fired now.
“Ah. Hang on.”
Graeme stood up, walked over to the decontamination bay, and pulled a chemical nose out of one of the drawers. She swabbed the wrench, looked at the readouts, and then sprayed some foam onto it. She was talking to the bot, too quietly for Benny to hear.
“Let’s give that a second to work. And then, I think it’s time we paid a visit to the charging bays.”
Benny frowned.
“Why? What’s it doing?”
“It’s easier to show you than explain. Let’s get this puppy cleaned up first.”
Together, they rinsed off the foam and sprayed down the rest of the unit, then checked fresh chemical sniffer results. Through it all, MET-A28 clung to its shiny wrench.
“Okay, tell it to go recharge.”
Benny tapped the icons on the HUD menu, and the bot started to move. Benny turned to follow it.
“No, we’ll take the elevator. This way. You feeling better now?”
“Yeah. Sorry.”
“Nothing to be sorry about. Should’ve done this week one.”
The elevator started descending with a jerk. For a moment, it seemed very small. Benny concentrated on Graeme’s prosthetic hand, tapping on the rail. Graeme didn’t look worried.
The elevator dinged again. The doors opened.
“After you,” said Graeme.
According to the HUD, the bay they were looking for was to the right. The hallway was dark, with pale concrete floors and blue metal gateways punctuating its length. Sensor lights flickered on as they walked, but the bays remained dark. Benny could make out faint red and yellow charging lights in some of them.
They turned a corner, then hit the right number.
Graeme leaned past Benny and poked a panel on the wall. The charging bay lit up.
Benny didn’t say anything.
It was going take her a while to figure out what to say.
There were ten alcoves around the room, sized for the different bots. They slept—charged, they weren’t alive—nose-in, with their pointed ends tapped into the power supply and their round backs facing the room.
No two alcoves were the same.
One had a curling design of green and blue glass stuck to the wall above it. One had a canopy of wood fragments woven through with long-dead flowers. A small one, with a sensor bot tucked into it, bore lines etched into the wall, arranged into designs that looked almost like pictures.
And one alcove had a sunburst of flat, shiny metal.
“What is it?”
“We’re not really sure. Almost all of them do it from pretty early in the real-world portion of their training. We tried taking it away, but performance craters. If we reprogram them not to do it, they can’t sort the materials right. We even had a couple of digital ethologists from the university come study them.”
“And?”
“Their final report was all about bowerbirds collecting blue objects and bees following ultraviolet markings on petals. Best I could tell, it boiled down to ‘the bots think it’s pretty, and maybe that helps them understand their jobs.’” Graeme shook her head. “I’m sorry. I should’ve told you, it just slipped my mind. When a bots finds a decoration for its nest, we just let it do its thing.”
There was a beep from the hall. Benny was probably imagining things, but it sounded timid. The big blue metal reclamation bot was still holding the silver wrench in its extended arm.
Graeme pulled Benny aside. They stood in front of the charging bay with the glass curlicues while MET-A28 rolled in, rotated, and extended a small nozzle. One of its solvent jets, Benny realized. It pivoted from side to side, probing the air, then poked the nozzle into the gap between a fish knife and a flattened beer can. It sprayed the wall, retracted the nozzle, and pressed the wrench into the sticky patch. Then, it retracted its arm, rolled backwards, beeped once, and rolled forward onto its charging brackets. An orange indicator light lit up on its rear.
“Told ya,” Graeme said, “personality.”
She shrugged.
Benny shook her head.
“That’s so weird.”
Graeme shrugged again.
“Like I said, it’s just how they make sense of it all.”
On the way home, Benny watched the scrubby regenerated forest around the landfill give way to orchards and solar arrays, and then housing developments with orderly palms and oleanders around their gates. She got off at the Caladan Avenue station, where unruly nasturtiums overflowed out of chipped concrete urns, and went back to her apartment.
Her pencil case was where she’d left it when she unpacked.
She went back into the other room and pulled Jacko’s sketchbook out of the drawer.
When Mom had helped her set this place up, she’d put a comfy chair in front of the window. Benny shoved laundry off it, sat down, and opened the sketchbook.
There was the dorm at Benicia. On the next page, a seagull with a crab in its beak. A water bottle, casting a long shadow in the afternoon sun. The extended gun-arm of a mech. She flipped through page after page of drawings, some swift, bare lines, some slow and carefully colored in. She found the first of her own drawings, a sailboat in the bay. Jacko had added a mermaid swimming in its wake.
The drawings ended three quarters of the way through the book.
Jacko would never fill those pages.
But new images had started crowding the blank pages of Benny’s life. She knew how she’d sketch them. The bots. Graeme’s plastic hand. The curvilinear forms of nasturtiums. Mom positioning furniture. The memory of Jacko’s face. Benny could see them, rayed out like the bots’ mosaics.
Benny bit her lip, pulled a pencil out of the case, and began to draw.
She left them under a palmyra tree where She huddled overnight. I would say ‘slept,’ but I think no one there truly slept, unless, perhaps, the infants. I imagine they dreamt of the earth cracking around them.
Others were deep in drifts of white beach sand, itself made up of fragmented bodies of long-dead sea life.
She left them under a palmyra tree where She huddled overnight. I would say ‘slept,’ but I think no one there truly slept, unless, perhaps, the infants. I imagine they dreamt of the earth cracking around them.
Others were deep in drifts of white beach sand, itself made up of fragmented bodies of long-dead sea life.
One was flung on the red cement porch of a childhood home.
We did not know where any of Her was, so our gathering was slow as we retraced Her footsteps. First, of course, we had to find Her feet. They were the last pieces of Her to go, but our task was challenging because they were lost amongst many pieces of many people, desperate to find their own remainders, loved ones, and homes. Saththiya recognised Her stubby left big toenail amongst all the others and pulled out the entire foot.
Do you know that card game, ‘Memory’, where you have to remember the positions of face-down cards while you search for the other in the matching pair? Once we had Her left foot, we thought back through all we had seen in the walk through that body-yard. I won’t call it a graveyard, because that implies proper burials. Anyway, our tradition is to cremate, not bury.
The right foot was blacker and more swollen than the left, but Parvathi, holding the found foot by the heel, picked through the crawling flesh to the ditch where we had seen it.
Sitting in the middle of that place, amidst our neighbours and countryfolk, we put Her feet side-by-side. We let the maggots stay, because they had found a home and it was not for us to displace them.
Saththiya rummaged in the sack she had toted over her shoulder all this way. With clunks and rattles she pulled out a small jar of nail polish that looked just like what we’d used in childhood, miraculously still liquid.
We didn’t try to trim Her fractured toenails, but we painted them parrot-beak red and said a prayer to Amman. We made up the words, because none of us had been to a temple for years, nor recalled the language of prayers.
Saththiya and I painted our own toenails and each other’s fingernails for dance performances. Her amma plucked maruthonri leaves and crushed them to decorate our hands with dark green paste, and we sat together on her porch each watching that the other didn’t smudge, and a koel somewhere said kuooou, kuooou, and peace was guaranteed for those minutes because we couldn’t move until everything was dry orange and red.
I don’t know how many times this really happened. It has collapsed into one memory. All the hot mornings, all the cuckoos.
“The birds have begun returning,” Saththiya said, but I hadn’t heard a single kuooou since I exited the bus.
The two single feet could only shuffle, which meant walking took longer. We’d barely made it across the next field before the sky oranged. We couldn’t seek a guesthouse. Who would want rotting feet inside their home? And we couldn’t leave Her in a yard alone when She had already spent years lost.
Parvathi thought footwear might solve the problem of speed, as well as prevent Her feet falling apart. They couldn’t quite accommodate the swelling, but we hooked my sandals on anyway. Her feet didn’t move at all.
“They would not have been bearing much weight at the end,” sighed Saththiya. “They could barely shift themselves before the sandals. Should we carry them instead?”
“You bear them on your head if you like,” said Parvathi, as I reclaimed my mud- and maggot-stained sandals, “but they’ll need to get used to carrying weight again before long, and coddling won’t help.”
From that place we had just left came scritching and slurping noises you’d never hear from an intact human body. Saththiya, keeping watch for snakes, used up the torch batteries lighting the grasses whenever a rustle came too close. We slept little, and all there was to eat when the sun rose was the kūdduchchātham we’d lacked the appetite for last night, gone sour in a dappa knocking around in Saththiya’s sack. We tossed it out to feed whatever birds and memories of life remained.
I missed home. Homes: the one I could never return to and the one I must return to when my visa expired. But my homesickness wasn’t the issue. Even when we were girls, merely ducking under the fences or down the lane to playmates’ houses for a game of hide and seek or carom, none of us willingly returned home without finishing what we’d started. The problem was that I had only a month-long visa, and we needed Kottravai.
Her feet led us to the outskirts of a village where She’d last truly slept, under a woven palmyra-leaf shelter. Her ankles were torn as if an animal had been chewing on them. Everyone had gone hungry, towards the end.
We guessed which side was which, and I sewed them to Her feet. Saththiya brought out silver anklets from her sack. They couldn’t reach all the way around the swelling, so we tied them on with a piece of cotton thread. The bells rang alongside us as we walked.
Parvathi and I lived on the same road. She came to my house before school every day, and we walked to the bus stop together. I don’t remember it being so hot then, but maybe that’s because I have acclimatised to a colder latitude now. Maybe it’s just another misremembering. We shared our lunches under the sprawling fig tree and studied together.
Every thai pongal, the first visit would be between our houses, one of us bringing the other the pongal we’d just made. We might have returned home from university and continued that way, if it hadn’t been for the war.
“We should be grown women together. Instead, I am a blood-drinking pisasu,” she says. “What an injustice.”
I agree that this is a terrible injustice. I continue not to ask how she died. There’s no good answer, and she’d tell me if she wanted.
She doesn’t drink any blood that I can see.
The only strangers here are those in military or police uniforms and pale-skinned tourists. In our childhoods, they were rare.
Despite all the other changes, thanks to our language and dress and the way we move, we still don’t need to be recognised through a village or a relative’s name to be welcomed. As we continued into the hamlet, a woman washing clothes beside a well said, “You must be here for those legs.”
That got us all the way up to Her knees, leaning against a garden fence. The woman had discovered the legs beneath a palmyra and constructed a small lean-to outside her garden to shelter them instead. The lower part of Her sari was still wrapped around them—brown stains, red hibiscus print, greying cream background—so we only had to brush off the dust. The householder gave us buttermilk and sat quietly with us to watch me stitch.
She was satisfied, when we took her guests on our departure, and didn’t ask who they were. “One must be blessed to have such sisters,” was her farewell to us.
I had watched the war in ink-on-newsprint and pixels on a cathode ray tube screen, felt only in delayed chest squeezes and stomach churns and sleepless nights what others lived through, or didn’t. When Saththiya and Parvathi met me at the bus station, they’d appeared thin and old. They told me I’d lost weight.
I had left home before I developed the skill of commenting on other people’s weight. “You look just like your amma,” I told Saththiya instead.
“She asked after you.” Her voice had changed, or was it that for over a decade I’d only heard it down a calling-card-crackled phone line?
“And Parvathi. I hadn’t believed we would see you again.” I didn’t know what to say to her. It’s a blessing to be with her again, after we didn’t have a chance for a final farewell. I don’t understand how any of this works. What determines who returns from the dead?
“Who else could make sure you do this properly?”
I wasn’t sure what she meant, and I was distracted trying to fill in both their histories from small gleanings. The village they’d been in during that displacement, that evacuation. The fates of relatives, neighbours, familiar faces. They asked about my life, while I tried to reconcile the rubble with my childhood memories, avoiding questions that might pain them.
Then Saththiya said, “There’s one way we three can help.”
Others were putting overseas money into rebuilding temples and funding prayers as well as orphanages and hospitals, but my friends had a different idea.
We found Her fingers next. They were curved around a burnt kudam in the fractured hall of a school where many had hidden. No one else had left their fingers behind, though. I imagined She might have been fetching water or cooking for the others. We tried to pry one set of fingers from the neck of the kudam, but they squished under our hands, and the greenish stuff that leaked out looked and smelt like the scum in a sewage canal. The only option was to bring the kudam, and to carry the fingers that had oozed off, because Her legs, although they strode alongside us now, could not. I wrapped them in a scrap of fabric from Her torn sari and took them in my hands. When that bundle soaked through, Saththiya tore the mothalaippu off her own sari, and we bandaged them back onto the kudam. Parvathi carried it against her hip, wrinkling her nose, one of the only things she could carry for us.
I remembered how these fingers had worked the gardens with us. I breathed deeply, trying to take in what was left of Her, even if it was corrupted by decay.
Leaving the wrecked mandapam, we passed another group of searchers. I recognised the way their gazes scanned the shell-shattered landscape, the burnt tops of palmyra trunks, the distant horizon.
Everyone wanted to put their loved ones back together, but only some, like Kottravai, could ever be recovered. This cluster of workshoppers carried a head with a small strand of jasmine wrapped around a flimsy topknot. They were singing to their god to come to them, to bring peace, to cool their eyes.
When I looked again, I saw that the head was a coconut.
“That’s a possibility,” said Parvathi, following my gaze. But I wanted as much of Her as we could salvage, not some imagined re-creation.
When Kottravai lived alongside us, we thought nothing of it. To plant, water, and harvest was daily life, not worship. We had all felt Her absence for the first time after we left—or were displaced—and daily life no longer existed.
I’d thought I might find Her again when I placed a spider plant on the mantlepiece above the fireplace or when I soaked an avocado seed until it sprouted—but there was only one Kottravai for us, and She stayed at home and broke, until there was not enough of our home left to hold all of Her.
Her hands were at Saththiya’s house. Saththiya’s family had locked the doors and left when the bombs started landing too close, and they hadn’t been back. If it weren’t for Her feet leading the way, we’d never have learned She had stopped there.
Saththiya wept when we arrived, a moan creeping up her throat upon seeing the weed-smothered garden and the unswept path, the roof tiles in shards. I took the sack from her so she could cover her face with her hands, and we retreated out of sight of the gate until she felt ready to speak. At least her home was largely intact, but it was cruel to say that. For all I knew, she was crying with relief. There was a new distance between us, as wide as the oceans I’d flown over.
Someone rose from a cane chair on the ruined portico to greet us, offering seats before she knew who we were. She didn’t apologise when Saththiya said this was her home. They only used two rooms, she said, and kept those tidy. We didn’t ask for her story, but we heard it anyway.
In the bedroom, Her hands rested on the almirah. What must She have thought when She returned to find the house closed and empty?
Saththiya’s old comb was half-embedded in a palm, encrusted fluid sealing them together. “Do you remember She used to oil our hair and search for lice?” Saththiya said. “Maybe She came here expecting us.”
“The neighbours would have told Her you left,” I protested. “You can’t blame yourself.”
While Saththiya walked around her old home with its new residents, getting to know them, I sewed the separated fingers onto Her hand with the comb, curling them around it, and sewed the fingers attached to the kudam onto the empty hand. Her feet and legs leaned against the edge of the bed.
Parvathi waited until I finished sewing to say, “They’re the wrong way around.”
I hadn’t noticed. When they’re detached and still, fingers don’t have obvious left-right orientations. “Well, She couldn’t have held a kudam and a comb with the same hand.”
We studied my handiwork. ‘Hold’ was generous. I’d made good use of the strips of nylex sari to keep Her digits and palms together. I tidied my sewing things into my handbag and Parvathi rummaged around the drawers. “What nice clothes Saththiya had! All these silks. Oh, and look at the embroidery on this! We should take it with us, it hasn’t been eaten one bit.”
“It’s the mothballs.” They nauseated me, on top of the odour of rot. Parvathi grabbed a few of the small white pellets and bent over Her feet. I stopped her before she could drop mothballs in the holes. “The maggots are there already. We could try to keep them away if they weren’t, but it wouldn’t be right to—”
“Seri, seri, I know.” She looked up from the pile of clothes she was making as the door opened. “Can you keep these things?”
Saththiya picked up the kudam and hands and sat heavily on the bed with them on her lap. “She visited, when we first moved here. She helped dig the garden.”
“At least She got to see it again. Maybe She stayed awhile,” I suggested. “You could have sheltered Her without knowing. She might have used your things, otherwise why would She have picked up the comb?”
“If She’d had any hair left to comb, wouldn’t we have found it here?” Parvathi always had a snarky comment. “But we can take some of these things for Her. One of your saris, and look at these glass bangles!” The valuables had been taken by Saththiya’s family when they left. Or perhaps they’d been sold by the new occupants who, after all, had arrived with nothing. Only the bedroom seemed untouched.
Saththiya shrugged. “It’s not as if we’ll come back.”
The legs had taken a few steps forward and waited beside the doorway. “I guess it’s time to go.” She rose to open the door, and Parvathi shoved the bundle she’d pulled from the almirah into the sack.
A teenage boy brought us tumblers of tea before we left, and then it was a long walk through country lanes and towns until we found the rest of Her legs leaning against a palmyra. We recognised them from the hibiscus sari fabric. Saththiya hummed a song while I sewed. Her thighs were shrunken—everyone had lost weight in those last days—so it was complex work. I doubled back over my stitches to be sure they would hold.
She left Her hips and stomach on the beach to be lost under the shifting sand. We found them because Her fingers began drumming on the kudam as we approached. It took three of us digging—we did not expect Her fragile, fading fingers to help—to uncover it. Her legs waded into the shallows, between rags tangled in the rocks and dull-coloured plastic scraps, and Parvathi had to pull them back to shore, pleading with them to be careful at least until She was back together.
“They can’t hear you,” Saththiya said. “Just prop them in the sand.”
Parvathi dug another shallow hole where she placed Her legs side-by-side, kneeling with Her thighs against her shoulders, and scooped the sand we had excavated onto Her feet, until they couldn’t pull free. I stood bent over to sew them to Her hips.
Her stomach was empty, and Saththiya wanted to fill it before we sought Her ribs. With Pongal, she said, and I asked where we would find rice and milk on a coast that would only be known now for death.
With fish, suggested Parvathi, but she didn’t know how to catch them. She was the only one who could row a boat, and she could only move small objects, like mothballs and remains. She didn’t dare touch a living animal.
So we scraped the dust of our travel from our bodies, windblown beach sand pale with bleached coral fragments and funeral fire ash and the yellow soil and orange-brown soil and red-red soil from across our land, and they dropped in clumps from our hands into Her stomach cavity where the organs had rotted in the heat into a kind of mush.
Rebuilding should be beautiful, but it was only horrific.
Parvathi wanted us to start again and weave a new stomach of palm leaves. Saththiya insisted we would not remake any part of Her that we already had, however degraded. So much had been taken already that could never be replaced.
Palmyra trees are the life of this land: among other things, they provide fruit with the cool nungu inside; sweet karupaddi from its sap that ferments to kallu; bitter odiyal from the panangkilangu—the sprout; the leaves that can be woven for shelter or etched into olai chuvadi that may last hundreds of years; and timber. I see the fan palms standing charred and headless all across the landscape. If a god had a heart, I think this might break it.
We rarely talked of what might come next, or what we hoped for once we put Her pieces back together. Occasionally someone would say, “I wonder if it will rain?” or “Will the palms grow back?” and the others would respond with, “Maybe.” I suppose we had learned in wartime not to contemplate a future beyond survival.
We left the seashore and wandered a few miles inland to the next village, arguing. Should we start building up Her arms? No, it was hard enough carrying the kudam with Her hands. We’d look for Her upper body and build out from there.
As the walk continued, the days passed, and Saththiya and I grew hungrier and thirstier, we started wondering if we would find all of Her. We passed others accompanied by part-bodies, exchanging nods. We didn’t ask who their gods were.
We went to Parvathi’s old home next and found Her left forearm. It lay at the intersection of two old watering channels, or so Parvathi said. I remembered the garden that used to be here. Like Saththiya’s, it was overgrown. The forearm was a muddy, yellowing bone poking out of the dirt. We bound it around with banana leaves stripped from a nearby sapling, and I carried it.
We must have gardened with our families, not together, but nevertheless I have false memories of the four of us carrying a manveddi, guided by Kottravai, shifting the soil in these irrigation channels to determine where the well-water would flow. Of pulling weeds together, bare-handed. Of hacking down a huge clump of bananas. Of cutting leaves to feed the cows.
Parvathi smelt Her liver. It smelt like blood, she said, instead of decay. It was grey and faded and tucked into the corner between the half-wall and the house wall of the red cement portico.
My house, a few hundred metres further along the road, was completely gone—bulldozed or bombed, we didn’t know.
The neighbours had returned and rebuilt their home. They stopped us in the lane to warn that no one had checked my family’s land for unexploded mines.
“I can smell Her in there,” said Parvathi. “I’ll search. I can’t die twice.”
One day someone would discover what was buried in that soil. If we could unearth a lost Kottravai from all across the land, what might grow, or be built, out of the war debris concentrated here? I steered my mind away from that question. When Kottravai was here, She could help us face those terrors too. Maybe.
Though we’d mourned her once already, this Parvathi, this pisasu who might only be an echo or another fused memory like the cuckoos, felt like the real Parvathi.
Wanting to delay losing Parvathi for as long as possible, we finally change our approach.
We bundle together fistfuls of too-dry murungaikkai from a neighbour’s tree, forming the upper part of Her left arm and a full right arm. I sit on the ground and sew.
The neighbours still use their well, so Saththiya and Parvathi lower their sun-faded blue plastic bucket into the inch of water at the bottom and find an eye floating inside. Saththiya knots it into the mothalaippu of her sari.
There are no trees left in our garden—not the mangoes, the jackfruit, the papaya, not even a single banana tree from the plantation we’d grown. But as we turn back inland, carrying Her completed arms, we find Her head—Her real head—hanging empty-socketed from a coconut palm among the ordinary coconuts. Saththiya twists the eyeball into it like a lightbulb.
And that’s how it continues, alternating between the real and unreal.
Panai maddai, the lacey interwoven fibres surrounding the palmyra trunks, that we gather into matted hair.
Another eye in a temple pond, between flowering yellow water-lilies.
We cut long grass for the rest of Her torso, hoping the air inside it will be Her lungs. We slap handfuls of moist red soil around it, shaping a neck for Her head to rest on. With that done, we don’t need to carry any of Her.
We give Her our own blood—mine and Saththiya’s. Parvathi says, “So there is some use in becoming a blood-drinking pisasu after all,” even though she doesn’t drink any, only spits it back out to fill Kottravai. I’m just grateful to feel her touch again, however cold and clammy.
Before the war, the fruit bats used to swarm every night, over the temple and into the trees. Most of those trees are gone now, too. They can’t stand artillery fire any more than cement walls or stone pillars, and the flying foxes have nowhere to roost. We find a lone bat with one wing, and when it flutters, Parvathi says, “It’s Her heart.”
It wouldn’t survive alone, she argues. Why should we deprive it of this chance?
I refuse to sew—why should a bat recognise a human deity?—but it latches onto the ribs we shaped of blade-sharp palmyra stems and pulses there.
We dress Her in Saththiya’s sari. She still doesn’t talk. I think either Her hands or the glass bangles will break if I try to force them on. I have just five days left on my visa and need two of those for travel.
Saththiya takes my needle and thread and begins making a string of jasmine for Her hair instead.
“Do you think the bats are putting back together their bat-gods?” I ask.
We stay at a guesthouse that night. We can do this because not only is She shaped like a complete human, thanks to Her head, but the flowers almost mask Her smell now. That’s also how we know something divine is happening.
We make up another prayer before going to sleep. Saththiya and Kottravai share one bed, and me and Parvathi the other, careful not to touch. Drinking my blood once was scary enough, she says.
In the morning, as I’m stirring, Kottravai says in Her monsoon-rain voice, “I don’t know whether bats have gods,” and then, “We’d better get to work.”
“I’m dead,” Parvathi answers, holding the electric kettle. “I’ve done all the work I can.”
We say goodbye to Parvathi, again, sitting together with cups of tea that she could brew but not drink.
Kottravai gives her a last long hug, and she disappears while walking down the hall, just like a regular pisasu, between eyeblinks.
“We have much to do,” says Kottravai, sounding fresher and brighter with each word.
I want time to think about Parvathi. I wish I’d asked if she really slept when she lay next to us at night, and if she dreamed. I wish I’d spoken to her alone, sometime in the past few weeks, and not had only this shared farewell. But Kottravai’s appearance alarms me in a way that unearthing the parts of her body had not. Her oozing hand rests on her hip. The comb, separated from her fingers, lies wetly on the bedside table. I’m afraid she will try to tidy her uncombable panai maddai hair and pull it free.
Have we distorted her appearance too much, with too many substitutions? She only has two arms, and I thought a god would have many. And hearing her ordinary voice, I am uncertain whether She was even a god before. She may have been one of our mothers or aunts or grandmothers, or all of them—a misremembering of those who taught us to care for the land. They only had two arms each.
“We were never going to get her back as she was,” Saththiya murmurs. “You saw how the land is changed. What makes up Kottravai has changed.”
I expect her to demand seeds, or a manveddi, but Kottravai leads us along the hallway, green and brown and still decaying, and out onto the sun-scorched tar road.
“I want you to dig water tanks.”
“The two of us?” asks Saththiya.
“I don’t think these fingers would stay together for long.” Kottravai inspects her hands. “Water has always been the problem here. I wasn’t surprised about the temple tank but I saw with my own eye how low the well-water is.”
Saththiya and I look at each other. I wonder if it will rain, we’d asked each other.
We reach the bus stop, and Kottravai continues. “We can’t make it rain. The whole world has changed. Even if we hadn’t been ripped apart, we might not be able to make it rain. But I can tell you how to store water when it does. I can tell you what to plant, and when, and how.”
I want to tell her it’s not knowledge that’s lacking, only the capacity to do all of this on our own, and that’s what we wanted from her. But dear Saththiya, who understands more clearly than I do, says, “I’ll be able to find workers to help,” and turns to me. “Can you help get the money? When can you come back?”
Since when have our gods ever been a shortcut?
The rattling bus arrives, and as our decomposing Kottravai climbs the steps in front of me, maggots wriggling around her ringing anklets, I see that her feet don’t match at all.